"Better a fallen rocket than never a burst of light."
~ Tom Stoppard, The Invention of Love

Thursday, September 1, 2016

Red Cliff, Part 1 (2008, R)

I recently rewatched this incredible historical war epic by John Woo, and I liked it even better this time around.  I thought it was amazing the first time I watched it, and on seeing it again, it just gets richer.  Because this is a monster of a film bordering on five hours long, Woo wisely split it into two parts and released them separately in China.  (The U.S., less wisely, edited out the movie to oblivion and released one film at half the length.  Luckily, the full version is available on DVD.)  We’re looking at Part 1 today.

In 208 A.D., Cao Cao, Prime Minister for the Han Dynasty, manipulates the young emperor into giving him command of the imperial army.  His object?  Liu Bei and Sun Quan, two warlords in the South who oppose the emperor’s rule.  A brilliant military strategist named Zhu-ge Liang convinces the two Southern leaders to form an alliance; even though they have different aims and agendas, neither wants to fall by Cao Cao’s hand, and it’s only by banding together that they can have a chance of protecting their freedom.  Because the imperial army is vastly larger and much better equipped, the allied army must use inventive war tactics to win the upper hand.

While I’m not very familiar with the real Battle of Red Cliffs, the story is certainly a universal one:  the small but intrepid underdogs battling a juggernaut enemy.  Now, the Southern army has a handful of astounding warriors, and there are times when the film sends out the same four or five guys to let loose on the imperial soldiers.  This can sometimes be cheesy, like when Zhao Yun cuts his way through about a hundred soldiers while carrying a baby, but most of the time, it’s just stone-cold awesome, like when Guan Yu gets out from under dozens of spears trained on him and appropriates one of the enemy’s horses to escape with.  These are amazingly-cool action sequences that I love to bits, but I also love that these heroes aren’t the sole ace up the Southern army’s sleeve.  More than anything, they fight smart.  Zhu-ge Liang the strategist, along with Viceroy Zhou Yu, have a remarkable talent for getting into Cao Cao’s head, anticipating his movements, and responding with a battle plan that uses their limited resources to their greatest effect.  In Part 1, the “tortoise formation” battle is the highlight of the piece.  Brains, brawns, and skill all operating together to hold their own in a wildly outmatched fight – I love it so much.

I’m only familiar with a few of the actors here, though everyone is great.  Of those I don’t know, special mention to Yong You, who is very lowkey as General Liu Bei and yet totally conveys the air of a man people would follow, and Wei Zhao, who plays the fierce, independently-minded princess Sun Shang Xiang.  Chang Chen (Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, Happy Together) does well as the young Duke Sun Quan; you can feel his doubts fighting him as he considers taking on such an impossible foe.  However, the MVPs are definitely Takeshi Kaneshiro (Chungking Express/Fallen Angels, House of Flying Daggers) and Tony Leung Chiu-wai (most Wong Kar-wai films, Hero.)  As Zhu-ge Liang and Zhou Yu, they’re the symbolic faces of the alliance, and it’s such a treat to watch them work together, growing in their respect and regard for one another even as they know that, if they defeat Cao Cao, they might find themselves on opposing sides as their respective Southern leaders go back to fighting for their own interests.

Warnings

War violence, sexual content, and someone sticking their hand up a horse (it works in context.)

No comments:

Post a Comment