"Better a fallen rocket than never a burst of light."
~ Tom Stoppard, The Invention of Love

Thursday, July 20, 2017

Ms. Marvel, Vol. 6: Civil War II (2016)

The latest volume of Ms. Marvel is obviously part of something larger going on in the Marvel comics universe.  Even though I don’t know much about the overarching story besides the few hints other characters drop in lines here and there, there’s more than enough to get the general idea and be interested in how Kamala fits into it.

Kamala is still starstruck over the fact that she’s working with actual Avengers, especially the hero to whom she owes her superhero moniker, Carol Danvers.  When an Inhuman is discovered with a remarkable ability to determine the probability of crimes before they occur (basically, Minority Report with math,) Captain Marvel picks Kamala to head a task force field-testing this “predictive justice,” incarcerating would-be criminals before they have a chance to cause harm.  While Kamala is initially drawn in to the idea of stopping crimes before they happen, she soon begins to see the dark potential for overreach within the program.  Her evolving feelings stand to put her at odds with her hero, and her involvement in the whole thing puts her at risk of losing a lot more.

Even though this volume hinges on two pretty familiar plotlines – superheroes on the same side coming to physical and emotional blows over ideological differences, the problematic nature of arresting someone for a crime they have yet to commit – both aspects of it work quite well for me.  Whatever’s going down elsewhere in related comics, it’s interesting to see it from Kamala’s vantage point as someone who’s connected but still kind of in awe of these people.  Through her eyes, Captain Marvel and Iron Man being on the outs is like seeing the Avengers’ “mom and dad” falling out.  And as for Kamala’s part in the proceedings, I like that it develops gradually, that she starts on one side and gets caught up in it before realizing that it’s not everything she thought it was.  What happens here affects her on an interpersonal level, both among her superhero colleagues/idols and her close friends, as while as a personal one.  It really shakes her, what she thinks of herself and what she believes her purpose is as a hero.

Others stories, like the aforementioned Minority Report, have gotten into the thorniness of predictive justice before, but I really like how the volume ties it in with themes of profiling, police abuses, and mass incarceration.  Kamala gets into a terrific discussion with Tyesha on the subject, and just in general, it looks at criminals/potential criminals from a very humanized perspective and points to how branding someone a criminal before they’ve done anything wrong can create a self-fulfilling prophecy.  Really smart stuff.

Finally, there’s a fantastic narrative device here that gets a little into Kamala’s past, both her own and that of her family.  This is a heady story that messes a lot with Kamala’s head and has her exploring her origins and her place in the world.  The glimpses we get of young Kamala, Kamala’s mother, and Kamala’s great-grandmother (there are other ancestors involved, but the focal points are always the women) are a really beautiful way to delve into this, and it all culminates in a great section in which Kamala explores what it means for her to “go home.”

No comments:

Post a Comment