
*Episode premise spoilers*
Oh my god, what a fantastic episode! Soooooo funny—I was howling! Some really terrific stuff here for Joel Fry/Darren.
When Ollie discovers that Darren is moonlighting for a rival handyman, he’s deeply hurt by the betrayal and forces Darren to choose between them. Darren chooses Andrzej, though he quickly learns it’s not all it’s cracked up to be. Meanwhile, Emma tries to convince Ollie he’s just unloaded “dead weight” and promises to help him hire a much better assistant.
Many a sitcom has mined humor from framing a platonic relationship between two straight men as if it’s romantic, and this episode follows that trope pretty closely. After all, the episode is called “The Break Up,” and when Ollie bursts into the hardware store, angry that he’s been “cheated on,” Liz initially thinks he’s talking about Emma. There are only a couple of pointed gay jokes—Liz makes a Brokeback Mountain reference, then tries for Top Gun when Ollie doesn’t take the bait—but there aren’t any “no homo” moments.
There’s a major difference here compared to, say, J.D. and Turk or Cory and Shawn, and that’s that Ollie and Darren aren’t actually close friends. They’re a coworker comedy duo who spend a lot of time getting on each other’s nerves, and their most common dynamic involves Ollie failing to convince Darren to do any work. The “break up” between them is more about both guys not realizing what they had until it was gone, with the added “betrayal” aspect for Ollie. This brings a different tenor to the storyline. There’s less emphasis on “lol, Ollie and Darren are gay for each other!!” and more on using overt romantic beats to show Ollie missing his slacker assistant and Darren missing his cranky boss. The soundtrack gets in on this big time, and I love a wistful shot of both of them leaning against opposite sides of a fence.
This is such a fantastic episode for Joel Fry. Right from the start, Darren makes me laugh when he’s poking around a client’s pantry for food and asks Ollie, “Do I like oxtail soup?” He’s also really great in the scene where Ollie tries to get him to admit he’s been moonlighting, and I love Darren’s increasingly unsettled reactions to Andrzej’s over-the-top cheerfulness about his punishing work ethic. Also, Andrzej goes from zero to sixty in an instant—he tells Darren he’s like a son to him, which puts Darren in the crosshairs of his other assistant Jan. When Jan tells Darren it took six months for Andrzej to think of him as his son, we get this excellent exchange:
DARREN: “Six months isn’t so bad, you know, to be thought of as his son.”
JAN: “I am his son!”
DARREN: “What, biologically?”
JAN: “Yes!!”
DARREN: “Oh, right.”
The lines themselves might not seem like anything special, but when you pair Darren’s lowkey, slightly nervous energy with Jan’s manic agitation, it’s just great!
Side note: I’m glad to be reaffirmed here in my belief that, although Darren has a talent for avoiding work, he is actually a good handyman. I’ve said before that Darren is sharp and observant, and he used to work for Tony, who I don’t think would’ve put up with any shirking. I doubt Andrzej, who starts his work day earlier every time we see him, would put up with that either, so he wouldn’t have hired Darren unless he was good at his job. And losing Darren makes Ollie reflect on his skills, like when he tells his new assistant, “Darren had loads of mad tips like that. He’s like a…like a crazy genius.”
And holy crap, Joel Fry’s physicality! The man moves his body like a cartoon character, and I love it so much. This episode gives us 1) Darren standing stiffly bewildered while Ollie hugs him, 2) Darren scrabbling in vain to hoist himself over a fence, and 3) Darren literally “so pissed [he] can barely stand up,” staggering into a forward roll and then lying on his back with his legs in the air. Absolutely amazing, I adore it!

