
*Premise spoilers*
I had my back up a little going into this film, because I know One Battle After Another has been positioned as Sinners’s main competition in some of the big categories, and I’d heard it described as more of a “Black story for white audiences” film, compared to Sinners. On the whole, I’d say my feelings about the film are mixed-to-positive—there’s some good stuff here, as well as some frustrating stuff.
Back in the day, Pat was a revolutionary with his lover Perfidia. But then everything went sideways, and Pat had to flee with baby Charlene. Now named Bob and Willa, they’ve been hiding out for 16 years. When a powerful old enemy named Col. Lockjaw comes looking for them, Bob’s old comrades mobilize to help. It’s been a long time since Bob’s revolutionary days and he’s hopelessly out of his depth, but he’s bound and determined to protect Willa any way he can.
This movie is nominated for thirteen Oscars. Among others, they include Best Picture, Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Cinematography, and four acting nods.
One thing I appreciate is that this is not a Taken-style movie where Bob unleashes his deep well of lethal skills to rescue his daughter from the bad guys. Bob can’t do that. He’s spent the last 16 years in a drugs-and-alcohol-fueled stupor—he’s not remotely on his A-game here. He’s scrambling around in a bathrobe doing his best and looking for anybody who can help him.
That’s where the supporting players come in. The surviving members of the French 75, Bob’s old group of revolutionaries, are on top of shit. They’re the ones who tell Bob that Lockjaw is coming after him, and at that point, they’ve already extracted Willa and are taking her to a safe location. The trouble is, Bob doesn’t remember all the old codes and secrets, so he isn’t sure where she is. He needs help to contact them again and get the information he needs. This leads him to Willa’s karate teacher Sergio, who isn’t part of an established operation like the French 75 but who’s fighting the power on a more grounded level, protecting his immigrant community.
Then there’s Willa herself. Naturally, you can’t introduce a vile antagonist who’s hellbent on finding her and then keep her away from him the whole movie, and so eventually we see Willa in danger and separated from her allies/protectors. In her view, she’s been raised by a paranoid dad who flips out about her wanting to have a phone or invite friends to the house, insistent on staying off the grid. And she comes by that perspective honestly. In her life, she’s never seen any of the kinds of threats Bob has warned her about, and meanwhile, she’s had to bust his ass about driving drunk. But then she finds out it’s all real, and when she’s in the lion’s den on her own, Willa does whatever she can to stay alive. Good for her!
So I like that Bob is a mess who’s trying badly, that his friends—old and new—are the ones holding it down for the most part, and that Willa needs help without being entirely helpless. I’m less impressed with how Perfidia is portrayed/used within the story. She feels thinly written, much more like a device than a character. While Lockjaw is an effective enough villain, he’s honestly kind of repellent to watch onscreen. And really, there’s no reason this movie had to be over two-and-a-half hours long. I’ve seen Oscar movies this year that earned their length, but I don’t think this is one of them.
Like I said, there are four nominated actors here. Leonardo DiCaprio turns in a strong leading performance as Bob—he’s one of those actors that I think got the chance to be a lot more interesting after aging out of his heartthrob era. While this isn’t totally out of the ballpark of some of his other wild/unhinged roles, like his characters from The Wolf of Wall Street and Once Upon a Time in Hollywood…, he gets the job done. He’s funny, affecting, and intense as the story calls for, and he’s not afraid to look bad or ridiculous. For supporting actors, we have Sean Penn as Lockjaw and Benicio del Toro as Sergio. For my money, I favor del Toro here, and not just because Lockjaw is so terrible. Penn’s performance here is broad and actorly in a way that kind of “shows the strings” on the marionette, while del Toro’s feels much more organic and lived-in. And Teyana Taylor is recognized as a supporting actress in her brief role as Perfidia. To the extent that the character works for me, it’s because of what she does with it, not the writing. Beyond the award nominations, I want to shout out Chase Infiniti, who does a really nice job as Willa, and the always-great Regina Hall, who’s excellent as Deandra (one of Bob’s old revolutionary friends.)
Warnings
Violence, sexual content, language (including racial slurs,) drinking/smoking/drug use, disturbing images, and strong thematic elements.

