
Like Train Dreams, I went into this film not really sure what to expect but wound up enjoying it quite a bit. It’s another Richard Linklater/Ethan Hawke collaboration, a one-night-in-the-life biopic about lyricist Lorenz Hart. It’s well-written, an intimate story about a friendship breakup that’s equal parts moving and cynical.
It’s the opening night of Oklahoma!, the first Broadway musical Richard Rodgers did not write with his longtime partner Lorenz “Larry” Hart. Larry leaves the show at intermission to bolster his spirits at Sardi’s: talking the bartender’s ear off, promising he isn’t going to drink, and preparing himself to congratulate Richard and his new collaborator, Oscar Hammerstein II.
As far as troubled geniuses go, Larry feels both familiar and specific. He’s an alcoholic whose work is often misunderstood by the critics, whose ideas about musical theatre are out of step with a lot of the general audience (not to mention his own writing partner.) He likes incisive satire and distrusts honest sentiment, and he’s of the unfortunate opinion that Oklahoma! is a piece of trite drivel that will be far more popular than anything he and Richard wrote together. He’s deeply insecure and desperate not to show it. He’s brimming with ideas for a new four-hour-long musical epic, but Richard just wants him to commit to showing up when he says he will.
I really like the different connections we see throughout the night. Larry and Richard are the big one, of course, but theirs isn’t the only relationship we see in the film. Larry and Eddie, the bartender, know each other well and have an easy back-and-forth together. It’s clear that Eddie cares about Larry’s well-being and worries about his drinking, even as it’s Eddie’s job to serve him. While waiting, first for the arrival of his young lady friend Elizabeth and then Richard and his entourage to show up, Larry gloms onto a young GI playing the piano at the bar and a fellow drinker/writer who turns out to be E.B. White! And when Elizabeth finally comes? We already know Larry’s obsessed with her—he’ll tell anyone who’ll listen about her being 20 and him being 46, and that he’s pretty sure “tonight’s the night.” When she gets there, she asks almost immediately when he’s going to introduce her to Richard Rodgers, and yet it’s clear that they do have a special connection. Their repartee is effortless, and there’s just something about the way they interact with each other.
The film got two Oscar nominations: Best Original Screenplay and Best Leading Actor, for Ethan Hawke. The screenplay nod is self-evident. The dialogue sparkles in ways that stories about theatre writers often do, with a nice mix between witty banter and revealing monologues. The characters and their relationships depend just as much on the script as they do on the acting. As for Hawke, he’s very effective as Larry. It’s quite an “actorly” performance, and the movie loves using forced perspective/other film magic to show how short Larry is, but behind the hooks, there’s a lot of honesty here too. Larry is a man who’s deeply in pain and doing everything he can to distract from it—that comes through loud and clear in Hawke’s performance.
I enjoy the other performances too. I’ve loved Bobby Cannavale since The Station Agent, and he’s great as Eddie, playing very well off of Hawke. It took me a while to place Elizabeth, but she’s played by Margaret Qualley of The Substance—she’s wonderful in the role. I also like seeing the always-welcome Andrew Scott pop up as Richard.
Warnings
Sexual references/discussion, language (including homophobic slurs,) drinking/smoking, and strong thematic elements.

