I’m not
familiar with Jamie Mathieson, a new writer to Who this season, but I hear he wrote next week’s episode in
addition to this one, and I couldn’t be more relieved. Undisputed best episode of the season so far –
it feels like real, proper Doctor Who,
something that can’t be said about enough of the episodes this year. It just works for me on every level, and my overriding
thought while watching it was, “Finally!”
The
Doctor and Clara arrive on the Orient Express (in space,) a luxury rail of the future
with a 1920s flair. Mostly; these future
humans aren’t entirely up on their 20th-century history (keep an eye
out for the sultry singer vamping on Queen’s
“Don’t Stop Me Now.”) Because this is Doctor Who, the fun romp turns deadly in
a matter of seconds – 66 of them, to be precise – as passengers start dropping
dead after screaming about an assailant only they can see. Trapped on a moving train in space with a mythological
murderer, the Doctor has to discover his unseen foe’s secrets before it takes
every life onboard.
Where
to start? There’s the lavish set and
costume design (Clara looks darling in a stylish ‘20s dress,) the genuine
thrills and taut mystery, the humorous Who-ish
touches (in addition to the anachronistic song choices mentioned above, there’s
a fantastic gag with the psychic paper, and the Doctor makes unexpectedly
whimsical use of a cigarette case,) and the fine well of supporting
characters. The episode touches on
themes from elsewhere in the season, but whereas they’ve made me grit my teeth
in earlier episodes, they’re explored far more thoughtfully here.
I don’t
know where the show has been hiding this Doctor, but this is the one I
want. He’s brusque and arrogant, and he
keeps people at a distance, but he’s also brilliant, funny, wonderfully competent,
and not nearly as detached as he purports to be. He’s the man
in this episode, the Doctor I knew Peter Capaldi could be, and what’s more, we
actually get a good chunk of story from his perspective. This season has spent far too much time
looking through Clara’s eyes – not that her viewpoint is a bad thing, but we
need both, and it’s been frustrating to feel like the Doctor is the
curmudgeonly alien sidekick on his own show.
This episodes lets us see him having fun, working hard, making tough
decisions, being a hero, and hinting at the emotions he clearly still has,
despite his pricklier new personality.
At first,
I thought the episode was glossing over the interpersonal stuff from last week,
but while it definitely seems we’ve moved from point A to C or D, the issues
between Clara and the Doctor are addressed from both sides here. The crack that’s grown through their
friendship gets a lot of focus, there’s some good soul-searching, and the final
scenes between them are just what I would’ve liked to see after my jumbled
ranting at the end of last week’s review.
Really,
my only gripe isn’t about the episode itself; it’s the fact that it’s episode 8, and there are only four left this
season. It’s fine to tell a story about
the Doctor and his companion having trouble connecting after a regeneration,
but it’s not a story you want to spend two-thirds of the season telling. I should not
feel like I’m finally seeing the Doctor the show wants me to see. Why wasn’t I getting this weeks ago? Also, if we go right back to the Doctor
insulting Clara’s appearance, being ridiculously, distastefully prejudiced
against soldiers, and making hardly any tangible contributions to the adventure,
I might have to throw something.
No comments:
Post a Comment